By Patty Hampton, Managing Director, Staffing Services/Executive Search Consultant
Have you ever been told by a hiring manager to let a candidate “sit a while” after an offer has been extended?
Two weeks ago, I had to make up a bogus, out of body and inauthentic response to a well qualified candidate about a position that has been open for months. As I was going through my recruitment tracking report this morning, my mind wandered and I caught myself speaking out loud about the organization and the open positions. There were several unedited explicit words that crossed my mind, but a few edited and other miscellaneous thoughts that filtered the air as I took another sip of the morning Joe.
“Seriously? Why the heck is the position open if you have no urgency to make a decision?”
“ Ugh, I hate it when hiring managers act like they need to see 900 people to make up their mind.”
“Let’s see what inauthentic line can I make up today to keep this candidate warm.”
“Great, I’ve got seven more positions to fill and they are dragging their butts about two others. Dang, their killing me!”
“Are you kidding me? Really? They can’t afford to give this guy $2,000 or $3,000 more a year?”
“There is no internal equity issue, this job is unique and this sit and wait approach is costing me time and wasted energy. How about I just share the God’s honest truth about the situation that the salary request is the real issue and, offering more money is just not doable!”
My friends and colleagues will tell you in a heartbeat that I took the road less traveled and went with the authentic response and told the God’s honest truth. My decision was easier knowing that the candidate was still interested in the position and the organization. After more than 20 years as an HR practitioner and recruiting professional, I really don’t have time to play games.
I can hear some of you now, “You think the hiring manager’s decision was a negotiation tactic?”
No. I don’t think so. I don’t know what it is, but it has nothing to do with negotiation tactics; it’s just a plan and simple dumb move.
Time and time again I witness candidates that truly invested in an organization’s recruiting and selection process. Not only have they been interviewed by HR, but possibly a team of folks throughout the organization. My goodness, do we really need all these decision makers mudding up processes that we control? And at what point do you step in and do your due diligence and diplomatically let the hiring manager know, this is the best matched candidate and they’ve been blessed by everyone on your team? How can we say we balance the internal process with external factors when we know full well that we are the ones calling the candidates and scheduling them yet again for another freakin’ interview?
This is crazy people. Wake up!
We cannot allow hiring managers to control HR processes when we have a responsibility to drive change in our organizations. We are the change agents, right? When you know a candidate has been interviewed by a team of people and there is no definitive reason to bring them back again, then don’t. Force the hiring team or hiring manager to make a decision. There is no such thing as a “no risk” hire.
We have got to force our hiring managers to be better decision makers in the hiring and selection process. We have got to drive the process from the very beginning and that starts with us. Set up expectations of the recruitment and selection process. Balance out this so called power they think they have by injecting their preferences into the process. Don’t let hiring managers drag their feet when all the lights are green. Yellow means proceed slowly and I agree that we need to move forward with caution. But for God’s sake, we are in the business of changing lives. When you know you are impacting someone’s life by extending them an opportunity because they are one or two mortgage payments away from being homeless, trust me, you will respond differently. Especially when there are no red flags that hinder the process.
All I’m saying is, if you’re supposed to be the catalyst for HR processes in your organization and it’s your turn to take a swing at the plate, then by golly hit a home run.
I’m took a stand this morning and told a candidate the truth. The next move is yours. What are you going to do?